See Kendall Jenner, Selena Gomez And More Reminisce About Their First Vogue Covers

With Vogue‘s reputation as the fashion bible, it’s no wonder even big-name celebrities like Kendall Jenner and Kirsten Dunst still recall their debut cover with much excitement. When Cindy Crawford first saw her portrait in newsstands, she picked up three copies of the magazine (and the salesperson failed to recognize she was on each cover). Jennifer Aniston likened the experience to winning the million-dollar sweepstakes, while Ruth Negga was so skeptical that she rang her publicist multiple times to make sure her cover wasn’t a joke. And to Selena Gomez, the moment fulfilled “a little girl fantasy dream.” Here, in honor of the famed glossy’s 125th anniversary, these A-listers and more reminisce about the glitz and glam that come with being a Vogue covergirl.