We love celebrating Halloween as much as the next gal, but when it comes to our manis, we like to choose something we won’t get sick of after a couple days. If black isn’t already a staple in your nail polish palette, now’s the time to experiment with the moody hue. And since you’re already investing in a new polish anyway, we’ve rounded up 5 of our favorite black nail lacquers that look just as chic past the 31st—because there’s nothing scarier than spending your money on a 1-time use item.