14 Black Lipsticks For Halloween — & How To Wear Them Long After
If you're a procrastinator, you're probably trying to pull a last-minute Halloween costume together as we speak. Sure, you could team your classic LBD with a strand of pearls and go as Audrey Hepburn, or don that sequined sweatshirt in the back of your closet and call yourself a disco ball. Where's the fun in that, though? As an alternative, opt for a swipe of black lipstick for Halloween to get in the spooky spirit — which, in theory, should be the easiest option.
But the challenges of pulling off black lipstick are many: figuring out which shade of black is right for your skin tone; finding a black lipstick that won’t dry out your lips; setting it so that it doesn’t smear all over your face (as you nibble on yet another mini Snickers bar).
It all starts with figuring out the right shade of black for your skin tone. “The lighter your complexion, the darker you can go,” Gilbert Soliz, a Global Makeup Artist for Marc Jacobs Beauty, tells The Zoe Report. “If there’s more depth in your skin, that indicates you would benefit from a deeper berry or eggplant tone.” A true black, like MAC’s In The Spirit or Dior's Ultra Night 47, works well for lighter skin tones, while the purple-tinged Bite Beauty Matte Creme Lip Crayon in Black Truffle will pop against deeper complexions.
In addition to skin tone, you should consider how you want to wear black lipstick. “If you’re going for a vampy look, go with a purple undertone,” makeup artist Amber Amos tells us, like Givenchy Rouge Interdit Vinyl Color Enhancing Lipstick in Noir Revelateur. “If you’re going for a goth look, try a more blue undertone.” Bite Beauty Amuse Bouche Lipstick in Squid Ink is the perfect navy-meets-midnight shade to bring out your inner Wednesday Addams.
Next is prep. “Exfoliate and hydrate,” Nina Soriano, a makeup artist whose work regularly appears in Elle and Harper’s Bazaar, tells TZR. “When using a high pigment product of any color, it’s important to first take the time to gently exfoliate the lip, and then add lip balm to moisturize your lips.” Give the balm a few minutes to sink in before adding any color.
You can always use a dark black lip liner to fill in your lips first, but a long-lasting black eyeliner may actually be your best best. “Fill in your entire lip with a long wear black eyeliner,” Alexx Mayo, Mariah Carey’s makeup artist, advises TZR readers. “Really take your time creating the shape you want to achieve.”
Once your lips are fully lined, go in with your preferred shade of black lipstick. Soliz swears by Fenty Beauty’s recently released Stunna Lip Paint in Uninvited — “It's a long wear matte black that’s like Halloween, but fashion” — while Amos cites the affordable CoverGirl Katy Kat Matte Lipstick in Perry Panther as a moisturizing option that “has a more satin finish but also great pigment.”
“Should you decide to pick a matte tone, don’t forget that a little lipgloss can give it more dimension and alter the tone of your lipstick,” Soriano advises. A touch of Bite Beauty French Press Lip Gloss in Black Coffee on the center of your bottom lip will add shine — and make your lips look a little plumper, too.
To keep your black lipstick in place all party long, make sure to clean up the edges with concealer. This will define your shape and keep the color from bleeding past your lip line. One final hack for last-all-night lips? “Press a deep black eye shadow on top for a super matte black lip,” Dillon Pena, an editorial makeup artist, tells us. “If you’d like to add sheen to the black lipstick, use a black metallic eye shadow instead.”
That being said, “There's really only one rule," according to Soliz. "Wear it with confidence."
Lipstick Matte in In The Spirit
MAC's inky black matte lipstick would look wickedly good with your costume, a pair of jeans and a cute top, a gown for formal event... really, anything.
Matte Creme Lip Crayon in Black Truffle
The sharp tip of this crayon allows you to apply as carefully as you'd like.
Rogue Dior Ultra Rogue in Ultra Night 47
Dior's new lipsticks have great pigment and endless moisture, thanks to the plant-based oil fused into each tube.
Rouge Interdit Vinyl Color Enhancing Lipstick in Noir Revelateur
If you're shy, you might want to stay away from this shade — it's a vinyl color, meaning that it's got some serious shine.
Amuse Bouche Lipstick in Squid Ink
Technically, this is a deep navy — which makes it even more wearable after the day of scares.
Stunna Lip Paint in Uninvited
Rihanna closed out #StunnaWeek (where she dropped four new liquid lipsticks) with Uninvited, a soft matte that looks good on everyone.
Katy Kat Matte Lipstick in Perry Panther
French Press Lip Gloss in Black Coffee
There's real cold press coffee oil in Bite's French Press glosses, so your lips don't just look good — they'll feel good, too.
Limited Edition Halloween Color Statement Lipstick in Black Spell
“This one is a real gem and also a fantastic price point,” Soriano says. “It’s a great hydrating lipstick. It’s a limited edition color, but definitely one to watch if you’re in the market for a black lipstick.”
Powermatte Lip Pigment in Paint it Black
Makeup artist Marco Castro suggests NARS Powermatte Lip Pigment in Paint it Black, which magically works against all skin tones and undertones.
Long Lasting Liquid Lipstick in The Bronx
Ofra’s 50+ shade range has literally every color you’ll ever need — including The Bronx, a dark-as-night matte black that has a mysteriously hydrating feel.
Matte Lipstick in Midnight
Anastasia Beverly Hills
“Anastasia Beverly Hills in Midnight is a great option,” makeup artist Sean Harris tells The Zoe Report. “For some added dimension, press a shimmery shadow in the center of your lip with your finger.”
Vice Lipstick Comfort Matte in Perversion
"Comfort Matte" roughly translates to: The matte finish you want, paired with the creamy hydration your lips crave.
Super Lustrous Lipstick in Midnight Mystery
To make sure this silky, moisture-infused formula from Revlon doesn’t bleed, don’t skip the lip liner.