There are certain things you come to expect every Halloween: You will be asked 500 times what your attempt at a DIY costume is supposed to be (ugh), you will see every type of “sexy” animal represented, you will wake up with major wig head, and you will eat more candy than you said you would. The good news is, we might be able to help you out a bit with that last one. We’d never tell you not to indulge a little on this sweets-filled holiday—if we did we’d be total hypocrites—but may we offer a few options of confections that at least aren’t loaded with icky artificial ingredients? We’ve tracked down six kinds of candy that you can feel a little less guilty about snacking (notice we didn’t say bingeing) on, whether it’s because they’re made with healthy fats like coconut butter, antioxidant-packed dark chocolate, real fruit juice, or natural cane sugar. Enjoy!