(Travel)
TZR 2025 Readers’ Choice: Best Southeastern Island Hotel
Where the waves roll in and the sweet tea never runs dry — which hotel tops the list?
Craving an idyllic and indulgent island getaway sans passport? TZR’s Readers’ Choice Awards for Best Southeastern Island Hotels will certainly deliver – and then some. From the sugar-soft sands of Florida’s Gulf Coast to the charming barrier islands of the Carolinas, the following winners are pure coastal magic. Think barefoot luxury at Little Palm Island Resort & Spa in the Florida Keys, timeless elegance at The Cloister on Sea Island, and oceanfront indulgence at The Sanctuary at Kiawah Island Golf Resort. Each winner on this list promises a truly unique escape that blends laid-back island vibes with five-star sophistication, making them the kind of places you’ll dream about long after your tan fades.
Have questions? Read the official Readers’ Choice rules.
1. The Pensacola Beach Resort
Pensacola Beach, FL
Set on the powdery white sand beaches and aquamarine waters of Florida’s Emerald Coast, The Pensacola Beach Resort offers the Florida high life between two shores. Explore a wide range of maritime activities, or just soak up the coastal elegance on your balcony or poolside at The Tiki Bar.
2. The Islands Of Islamorada
Islamorada, FL
With 22 oceanfront villas and eight intimate ocean-view suites, The Islands puts the relaxed beauty of the upper Keys on full display. Laid-back luxury at its best, the resort offers direct marina access for those yachting in, and pooch-friendly accommodations so you can bring your entire crew, four-legged members included.
3. Isla Bella Beach Resort
Marathon, FL
The contemporary glamour of Isla Bella Beach Resort raises the standard for oceanfront luxury getaways. Every room has a stunning ocean view and private terrace, thanks to over a mile of waterfront property. With five pools, incredible dining, and world-class fishing, it’s the ultimate private oasis in the Keys.
4. The Ritz-Carlton, Amelia Island
Amelia Island, FL
An elegant North Florida retreat with 13 miles of pristine shoreline, The Ritz-Carlton Amelia Island is where Southern charm meets coastal luxury. Enjoy a seaside escape with stunning ocean views from your balcony, tranquil spa experiences, exquisite dining, and private golf greens amid ancient oaks.
5. Kimpton Vero Beach Hotel & Spa
Vero Beach, FL
6. Little Palm Island Resort & Spa
Little Torch Key, FL
7. Opal Sands Resort
Clearwater Beach, FL
8. The Cloister
Sea Island, GA
9. Jekyll Island Club Resort
Jekyll Island, GA
10. The Sanctuary at Kiawah Island Golf Resort
Kiawah Island, SC
Photos courtesy of The Islands of Islamorada, The Jekyll Island Club, Opal Collection, The Ritz-Carlton - Amelia Island, Kiawah Island Golf Resort
