As any die-hard beauty girl knows, it’s important to play favorites. Now that we’re moving into colder months, we’re stashing our colorful eyeliners and breaking out our classic dark shades—more specifically, black. But while we love our go-to pencils, we keep going back to our kajal eyeliner as of late. It’s so easy to use: The creamy formula glides and smudges to perfection (hello, 2-second smoky eye) and it never needs sharpening (no more scratching your eyelid just to get a smidge of definition). Here, we’re sharing our star players so you can step up your liner game, stat.