Show of hands, who’s been that girl at the pool party having the time of her life, completely oblivious that her eyelids are covered in melted mascara? Yeah, us too. Here’s what we need to do: Get new friends since our old ones didn’t tell us we looked like a raccoon, and find a mascara that’s completely waterproof. To make sure you don’t get caught with messy makeup ever again, we tapped Internet sales and review tracker Rank and Style for the best-reviewed waterproof mascaras on the market. Scroll through for the top ten, and as for your quest for a new bestie, we’re always here to tell you when you need a touch-up.